Skip to Content

Hotel or Rental? Choosing the Best Dog-Friendly Lodging for Your Trip

0 Comments

Hotel or vacation rental—which one is better when you’re traveling with your dog?

It’s a question I’ve asked myself many times while planning trips with our pups in tow. We’ve stayed in both, and truthfully, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Each has its perks—and its drawbacks—depending on where you’re going, what kind of trip you’re taking, and of course, your dog.

When we’re headed into a city, we tend to book a hotel. They’re usually easier to find in the heart of the action—close to restaurants, attractions, and public transportation. Rentals, on the other hand, are often tucked into residential neighborhoods, which can mean a longer trek to tourist areas. Convenience wins out in those cases.

But for the quieter, outdoorsy getaways—like weekends in the mountains or summer stays near the shore—we almost always go with a vacation rental. Having a standalone home with a fenced yard or private space gives us more flexibility. It’s also nice to know we can leave our dog comfortably at the house if we want to visit a nearby beach or trail that isn’t pet-friendly.

Each option comes with trade-offs, but over the years, I’ve learned how to weigh the pros and cons to find the best fit for the kind of trip we’re planning. In this post, I’ll walk you through how to decide between a hotel and a vacation rental, what dog-friendly features to look for, and what red flags to avoid before booking.

Happyoodles.com Hotel or vacation rental? Cartoon pic of a large hotel next to a house with a person and dog in front of each one

Hotels vs. Airbnbs: Key Differences for Dog Owners

After deciding where to go on your vacation, the next question is where to stay: a hotel or a vacation rental? As I mentioned we’ve stayed in both many times, and I’ve found the right choice really depends on the kind of trip we’re taking.

Here’s a closer look at the key differences to help you decide what’s right for your next trip.

Hotels: The Convenient Option for City Stays

Hotels are typically located in prime areas—close to attractions, restaurants, and walkable neighborhoods. That’s a big plus when you’re visiting a city or passing through for just a night or two.

Pros:

  • Convenient locations: Hotels are usually in central, tourist-friendly areas—ideal if you want to be in the middle of it all.
  • Predictable standards: Chain hotels often have consistent policies, cleanliness, and check-in procedures, which adds peace of mind.
  • Short stays are easier: For a quick overnight or weekend trip, it’s often simpler to book a hotel than a multi-night rental.

Cons:

  • Limited space: Most hotel rooms are small, which can feel even smaller with a dog.
  • Strict pet rules: Many hotels don’t allow dogs to be left alone in the room, which means every outing needs to be dog-friendly—a tough ask in some places.
  • Fees and restrictions: Pet fees are common, and some hotels limit dog size or breed. Always check the fine print.
  • Lack of outdoor access: Unless you luck out with a ground-floor room near a grassy area, potty breaks can be inconvenient—especially in urban areas.

Vacation Rentals: Flexibility and Room to Roam

For more relaxed trips—like heading to the mountains, countryside, or coast—we’ve found vacation rentals to be a better fit. They usually offer more space, privacy, and a home-like feel that makes traveling with a dog less stressful.

Pros:

  • More space: Rentals often include multiple rooms, a full kitchen, and living space—great for dogs who need room to stretch out.
  • Leave your dog behind (sometimes): Many hosts are okay with well-behaved dogs staying alone, which gives you the option to explore places that aren’t dog-friendly.
  • Quieter surroundings: Rentals in residential or rural areas can be less stimulating for nervous or reactive dogs.

Cons:

  • Not always budget-friendly: Nightly rates (plus cleaning and pet fees) can add up quickly, especially during peak seasons.
  • Location trade-offs: Rentals in cities are usually outside the main tourist zones, meaning you’ll likely need to drive or take public transit to get around (which may not be dog-friendly.)
  • Inconsistent quality and rules: Hosts vary widely in how “dog-friendly” their homes really are. Some allow pets but expect no signs of them afterward, which can feel stressful.
  • Outdoor access isn’t guaranteed: While many rentals offer fenced yards or patios, it’s not a given—especially in urban locations.
Hotel or rental: Which should you choose? Bella getting water at-the-Heritage-Area-Visitors-Center-Saratoga-Springs-NY
Bella atHeritage Area Visitors Center, Saratoga Springs NY

What Dog-Friendly Amenities Should You Look For?

Not all “pet-friendly” stays are created equal. Just because a hotel or rental allows dogs doesn’t mean it’s set up to make your stay easy—or enjoyable. Over the years, I’ve learned to look beyond the pet policy and dig into the details that actually matter when traveling with a dog.

Here are some key dog-friendly amenities to look for, broken down by type of lodging:

At Hotels

Hotels that welcome dogs vary widely in what they offer. Some go above and beyond, while others do the bare minimum. Before you book, check for:

  • Designated pet relief areas: Having a grassy spot nearby (especially one with waste bags and trash cans) makes late-night potty trips a lot easier.
  • Ground-floor or near-exit rooms: If your dog needs quick outdoor access—or struggles with elevators—ask for a room close to the exits.
  • Clear pet policy and fees: Look for hotels that clearly spell out size limits, pet fees, and whether pets can be left alone in the room (many don’t allow it).
  • Easy access to walking routes: Being near a park, a walking path, or even a tree-lined street makes a big difference for your dog’s comfort—and your own.
  • Pet welcome kits (at higher-end hotels): Some luxury hotels offer dog beds, bowls, and treats—but don’t assume these are standard. If that matters to you, confirm in advance.

At Vacation Rentals

Rentals often give you more flexibility and space, but the pet-friendliness can vary depending on the host. Here’s what to look for:

  • Fenced yard or secure outdoor space: A private yard is a huge plus, especially if you want to let your dog out without leashing up every time.
  • Pet-friendly furnishings (or clear rules): Some rentals allow pets but expect you to keep them off furniture or crated while indoors. Look for listings that are genuinely set up for dogs.
  • Proximity to parks or trails: Rentals near dog-friendly hiking paths, beaches, or parks make daily outings easier and more enjoyable.
  • Safe neighborhood for walks: Check reviews or use Google Street View to get a feel for the area—especially if you’ll be walking your dog at night.
  • Host communication: A responsive host who’s clear about pet expectations makes a big difference. I always appreciate when a listing includes detailed pet info right up front.

Red Flags: What to Watch Out For

Even when a place is labeled “pet-friendly,” that doesn’t always mean it’s actually welcoming—or convenient—for you and your dog. Over the years, I’ve run into a few surprises that could’ve been avoided with a closer look at the fine print or guest reviews.

Here are some common red flags to look out for when booking dog-friendly accommodations:

At Hotels

  • Unclear pet policies: If the hotel’s website doesn’t clearly state their pet rules, fees, or restrictions, it’s a sign to dig deeper. Always call and confirm before booking.
  • No pets left unattended: This policy is common, especially at mid-range chains. It means your dog can’t stay in the room alone—even if crated—which can limit your ability to explore non-dog-friendly places.
  • Excessive fees or deposits: Some hotels charge high pet fees or large, non-refundable deposits. Be sure to factor that into your total cost.
  • Poor outdoor access: A hotel without nearby green space—or one that requires navigating stairs or elevators for every potty break—can be a hassle, especially with older dogs.
  • Negative reviews about cleanliness or noise: Look for feedback from other pet owners. If previous guests mention issues like paper-thin walls, noisy hallways, or overly strict staff, it may not be a great choice with a dog.

At Vacation Rentals

  • “Pet-friendly” but with a long list of restrictions: If the listing says pets are allowed but includes rules like no pets on furniture, no barking, no being left alone, and extra cleaning requirements—it may not be as pet-friendly as it claims.
  • No mention of outdoor space: Some listings are vague or misleading about having a yard. Always look for photos or ask directly if the outdoor space is fenced and secure.
  • High or surprise fees: Cleaning fees, pet fees, and deposits can vary widely—and sometimes aren’t shown until checkout. Make sure you know the full cost upfront.
  • Lack of reviews mentioning pets: If no one else has reviewed the place with a dog, it might be worth reaching out to the host for clarification before booking.
  • Unresponsive hosts: If a host doesn’t reply to your questions or seems vague about pet expectations, that’s usually a red flag. It’s better to skip it than end up in a stressful situation.

Budget Considerations: The Real Costs of Traveling with Your Dog

When planning a dog-friendly trip, the nightly rate is just the starting point. Whether you’re booking a hotel or a vacation rental, traveling with a dog almost always comes with added costs—and those fees can add up quickly if you’re not careful.

Here’s what to keep in mind when budgeting your stay:

Hotels

Hotels often look more affordable at first glance, especially for short stays. But don’t forget to factor in the pet-related extras.

  • Pet fees: These can range from $25 to over $200 per stay or per night, depending on the hotel.
  • Deposits: Some hotels charge a refundable deposit, while others charge a non-refundable cleaning fee.
  • Parking and resort fees: These aren’t dog-specific, but they can sneak up on you—especially in urban areas.
  • Multiple dogs: If you’re traveling with more than one dog, expect additional fees—or restrictions on how many pets are allowed.

💡 Tip: Some hotel chains (like Kimpton or Red Roof Inn) are known for being more dog-friendly and may waive pet fees altogether.

Vacation Rentals

Vacation rentals tend to cost more per night than standard hotel rooms, but you often get more space and amenities. That said, dog owners still need to watch for hidden costs.

  • Pet fees or cleaning surcharges: These can be rolled into the cleaning fee or added as a separate line item.
  • Higher base price: Pet-friendly rentals are sometimes priced higher than similar non-pet listings.
  • Longer minimum stays: Some rentals require a 2–3 night minimum, which can make short trips more expensive.
  • Security deposits: Hosts may request a larger deposit if you’re bringing a dog, especially for high-end or historic properties.

💡 Tip: Check the full pricing breakdown before booking and look for hosts who clearly outline all pet-related charges up front.

Which is More Budget-Friendly?

If you’re traveling for just a night or two, a pet-friendly hotel may be more cost-effective—especially if it doesn’t charge steep pet fees. For longer stays or trips where you’ll need a kitchen or outdoor space, vacation rentals often offer better overall value, even with the added pet costs.

It really comes down to doing the math based on your travel length, destination, and how much comfort and space you need for your dog.

When to Choose a Hotel vs. a Vacation Rental

After staying in both hotels and vacation rentals with our dogs, I’ve found that the best choice often depends on the kind of trip we’re taking—not just price or availability. Each option comes with its own set of benefits, and knowing when to choose one over the other can make your stay smoother for both you and your pup.

When a Hotel Makes More Sense

  • You’re staying in a city or urban area: Hotels are typically located in the heart of downtown, close to restaurants, attractions, and public transit—no need to drive in from the suburbs.
  • It’s a short stay or a quick stopover: For one- or two-night trips, hotels offer more flexibility with check-in/check-out and don’t usually require a multi-night commitment.
  • You plan to be out and about all day: If you’ll be taking your dog with you most of the time, you may not need the extra space a rental provides.
  • You want consistent service: Chain hotels offer predictable standards, 24/7 staff, and easier check-in—even late at night.

When a Vacation Rental Is the Better Choice

  • You’re staying longer or need more space: Rentals usually offer more room for your dog to stretch out—and for you to cook, relax, and unpack.
  • You’re heading to the beach, mountains, or countryside: In more remote or scenic locations, it’s easier to find standalone homes with private yards or nearby trails.
  • You might need to leave your dog behind occasionally: Many rentals allow pets to stay alone in the house (check the rules), giving you flexibility to visit dog-free spots like museums or restaurants.
  • Your dog is sensitive to noise or activity: Rental homes tend to be quieter and more private than busy hotels with shared hallways and frequent foot traffic.

A little research upfront can go a long way toward making your trip smoother for both you and your dog. And if you’re ever unsure about something—don’t hesitate to ask the hotel or host before booking. It’s better to know the rules ahead of time than to be caught off guard after you arrive.

Finding the Right Fit for You and Your Dog

Whether you choose a hotel or a vacation rental, the most important thing is finding a place that works for both you and your dog. Think about your destination, your itinerary, your dog’s temperament—and yes, your budget. Each option has its trade-offs, but with a little planning, you can find a stay that keeps everyone comfortable and happy.

Have you found a great dog-friendly hotel or vacation rental?

Share your favorite places in the comments—we’d love to hear what worked for you! And if you’re planning a trip soon, check out our other dog-friendly travel tips for more help along the way.

Resources: